Distillation Paper: Can de-escalation training change what happens in the field?
Distillation Paper | Critical appraisal | 6 November 2026
Engel et al. (2022). Assessing the impact of de-escalation training on police behavior. Criminology & Public Policy, 21, 199–233. doi:10.1111/1745-9133.12574.
The discourse and the gap
De-escalation training was widely recommended, but recommending it was easier than demonstrating that it reduced force in everyday police work.
The research question
Would ICAT training reduce force and injuries in Louisville’s police department?
The study design
A stepped-wedge randomized trial staggered training across divisions in a randomly assigned sequence. This created comparisons while eventually delivering training throughout the department.
The methods and their weight
Researchers analyzed administrative force and injury records and tested alternative explanations involving time trends and policy changes. Randomized timing strengthens inference, but outside events and reporting practices remain concerns. One department cannot establish effectiveness across all agencies, populations, or correctional settings.
The finding that matters
The analysis estimated a 28.1% reduction in force incidents following training. Reported citizen and officer injuries also declined, an important check on whether reduced force came with a safety tradeoff.
Why it matters
The study connects training with behavior in the field. My reading: it supports further implementation with evaluation, not a universal promise. It tests ICAT in this setting, not CRG’s programs or every approach called de-escalation.

Comments